- Lori Ann Bugliaro P.A., PA,REALTOR ®
- Tropic Shores Realty
- Helping My Clients Make the Right Move!
- Mobile: 352.585.0041
- Fax: 888.519.7102
- Mobile: 352.585.0041
- loribugliaro.realtor@gmail.com
Contact Lori Ann Bugliaro P.A.
Schedule A Showing
Request more information
- Home
- Property Search
- Search results
- 2421 Prospect Street, SARASOTA, FL 34239
Active
Property Photos

- MLS#: A4677367 ( Residential )
- Street Address: 2421 Prospect Street
- Viewed: 37
- Price: $698,500
- Price sqft: $473
- Waterfront: No
- Year Built: 1956
- Bldg sqft: 1476
- Bedrooms: 3
- Total Baths: 2
- Full Baths: 1
- 1/2 Baths: 1
- Garage / Parking Spaces: 1
- Days On Market: 78
- Additional Information
- Geolocation: 27.3216 / -82.5214
- County: SARASOTA
- City: SARASOTA
- Zipcode: 34239
- Subdivision: Rustic Lodge
- Elementary School: Alta Vista
- Middle School: Brookside
- High School: Sarasota
- Provided by: FULLER GROUP
- Contact: Bo Fuller
- 941-961-3100

- DMCA Notice
-
DescriptionNow offered at a rare value... Welcome to 2421 prospect street in arlington parks tightly held rustic lodgethis elegantly refined florida mid century retreat with modern coastal finishes is rooted in sarasotas golden erathe 1950s marked a time when homes were designed & built with longevity & craftsmanship2421 is a beautiful reflection of that legacyapproached not as a renovation but as a custom crafted rebuild... A design conscious builder honored the original vision while elevating the residence to meet todays expectations for style, comfort, and qualitythe integrity, proportions, and character remain intact, now enhanced by refined finishes, seamlessly integrated contemporary systems, forward thinking infrastructure, and improvements aligned with city of sarasota codesleek, clean & effortlessly coolas though the 1950s walked into 2026 with styleexpansive new pgt impact windows, sliders & doors bathe the home in light while preserving tranquilityevery detail has been carefully considered, including all new plumbing with cast iron replacement under the slab, all new electrical, hvac ductwork, and engineered structural enhancements to create an open floorplan... Insulated interior walls in key areas, blown attic insulation, tankless water heater, fresh paint, white oak style plank flooring with four inch baseboards, frameless glass shower doors, custom walk in closets, and soft close cabinetry throughoutcurated quartz countertops extend across the gourmet chefs kitchen, catering pantry, dry bar, and bathroomsrecently enhanced with a brand new stainless steel lg dishwasher & new ge profile refrigeratoradditional home features include glass tile backsplashes, substantial kitchen island with tile accent lighting, and vented range hooddiscreetly integrated throughout is a fully automated smart home system offering complete flexibilityincluding remote entry keypads, wireless alarm, ring cameras, motion detectors, panic buttons, remote control ceiling fans, usb & usb c outlets, nest thermostat, and digitally controlled irrigationallowing the home to be fully automated or enjoyed traditionally at the owners preferencea fully screened lanai with custom tongue & groove ceiling extends the living space outdoors, complemented by new epoxy flooring leading to the paver patio with pool, spa & expansion concepts availablethe grounds have been curated with a six figure landscape & lighting package, fully fenced, double gated privacy, mature junipers, lush clusia hedges, olive trees, bird of paradise, and fragrant jasminea three bedroom, one and a half bath residence in the heart & soul of arlington parkjust blocks to legacy trail and arlington park & aquatic center hosting live music events alongside pickleball, tennis, basketball courts, playgrounds, a dog park, walking trails, and two poolsblocks to sarasota memorial hospital, minutes to downtown sarasota, siesta key, longboat key, anna maria island, utc mall, and a depth of dining & cultural offerings favored by localsjust a fifteen minute drive to sarasota bradenton international airportweekly rentals are allowed, not in a flood zone, no storm damage, no hoa, and offered turn key furnished or thoughtfully curated to buyer preferencespassed down through only two owners since the 1950s, this home represents stewardship, architectural lineage, and forward thinking livingits timeless, intentional, and unmistakably rareschedule your private tour today & live a fuller life!
Property Location and Similar Properties
All
Similar
Features
Appliances
- Bar Fridge
- Dishwasher
- Disposal
- Dryer
- Electric Water Heater
- Exhaust Fan
- Freezer
- Ice Maker
- Kitchen Reverse Osmosis System
- Microwave
- Other
- Range
- Range Hood
- Refrigerator
- Tankless Water Heater
- Washer
- Water Filtration System
- Water Purifier
- Wine Refrigerator
Home Owners Association Fee
- 0.00
Carport Spaces
- 1.00
Close Date
- 0000-00-00
Cooling
- Central Air
- Humidity Control
Country
- US
Covered Spaces
- 0.00
Exterior Features
- Courtyard
- Dog Run
- Fire Pit
- Garden
- Lighting
- Misting System
- Outdoor Grill
- Permeable Paving
- Private Entrance
- Private Mailbox
- Private Yard
- Rain Gutters
- Sidewalk
- Sliding Doors
Fencing
- Wood
Flooring
- Epoxy
- Luxury Vinyl
Furnished
- Negotiable
Garage Spaces
- 0.00
Green Energy Efficient
- Appliances
- Construction
- Doors
- Incentives
- Insulation
- Lighting
- Thermostat
- Water Heater
- Windows
Heating
- Central
- Electric
- Heat Pump
High School
- Sarasota High
Insurance Expense
- 0.00
Interior Features
- Built-in Features
- Ceiling Fans(s)
- Dry Bar
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Living Room/Dining Room Combo
- Open Floorplan
- Pest Guard System
- Primary Bedroom Main Floor
- Smart Home
- Solid Wood Cabinets
- Split Bedroom
- Stone Counters
- Thermostat
- Walk-In Closet(s)
- Window Treatments
Legal Description
- LOT 6 & W 4 FT OF LOT 8 & E 2 FT OF LOT 4 BLK B RUSTIC LODGE NO 2
Levels
- One
Living Area
- 972.00
Lot Features
- Historic District
- City Limits
- Landscaped
- Level
- Near Golf Course
- Near Marina
- Private
- Sidewalk
- Paved
Middle School
- Brookside Middle
Area Major
- 34239 - Sarasota/Pinecraft
Net Operating Income
- 0.00
Occupant Type
- Owner
Open Parking Spaces
- 0.00
Other Expense
- 0.00
Other Structures
- Shed(s)
- Storage
Parcel Number
- 2035020094
Parking Features
- Covered
- Deeded
- Driveway
- Off Street
- On Street
- Open
- Other
- RV Access/Parking
Pets Allowed
- Cats OK
- Dogs OK
- Yes
Possession
- Close Of Escrow
Property Condition
- Completed
Property Type
- Residential
Roof
- Membrane
- Shingle
School Elementary
- Alta Vista Elementary
Sewer
- Public Sewer
Style
- Bungalow
- Cape Cod
- Coastal
- Contemporary
- Craftsman
- Elevated
- Florida
- Historic
- Mid-Century Modern
- Ranch
Tax Year
- 2025
Township
- 36
Utilities
- BB/HS Internet Available
- Cable Connected
- Electricity Connected
- Fiber Optics
- Phone Available
- Public
- Sewer Connected
- Underground Utilities
- Water Connected
View
- Garden
- Trees/Woods
Views
- 37
Virtual Tour Url
- https://listing.noblesandheroes.com/vt/2421_Prospect_St.html
Water Source
- Public
Year Built
- 1956
Zoning Code
- RSF4
Disclaimer: All information provided is deemed to be reliable but not guaranteed.
Listing Data ©2026 Greater Fort Lauderdale REALTORS®
Listings provided courtesy of The Hernando County Association of Realtors MLS.
Listing Data ©2026 REALTOR® Association of Citrus County
Listing Data ©2026 Royal Palm Coast Realtor® Association
The information provided by this website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.Display of MLS data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.
Datafeed Last updated on April 8, 2026 @ 12:00 am
©2006-2026 brokerIDXsites.com - https://brokerIDXsites.com
Sign Up Now for Free!X
Call Direct: Brokerage Office: Mobile: 352.585.0041
Registration Benefits:
- New Listings & Price Reduction Updates sent directly to your email
- Create Your Own Property Search saved for your return visit.
- "Like" Listings and Create a Favorites List
* NOTICE: By creating your free profile, you authorize us to send you periodic emails about new listings that match your saved searches and related real estate information.If you provide your telephone number, you are giving us permission to call you in response to this request, even if this phone number is in the State and/or National Do Not Call Registry.
Already have an account? Login to your account.
